Raleigh NC Feb 19 2013 A case that started with the arrest of a 19-year-old Elon University student in 2010 for underage drinking and resisting an officer is forcing the N.C. Supreme Court to decide whether campus police at private colleges must be as transparent as their municipal law-enforcement peers.
A reporter for a campus television news program asked Elon University’s police chief for a copy of the arrest record. What Nick Ochsner received said nothing about whether the officer had to chase down the student or how he was alleged to have resisted arrest, his mother, attorney Ann Ochsner, said.
The campus police said it didn’t have to produce anything more because, as part of a private university, a state law requiring a government agency to turn over public records on request didn’t apply.
The supreme court heard arguments Wednesday in Raleigh in a case that could define the role of officers who aren’t clearly public officials yet have arrest authority that other private employees don’t have.
Chief Regina Lawson of the Wake Forest University Police Department said Thursday that she, her agency and other police departments at the state’s private colleges are following developments in the Elon case.
“Our practice is to release the public incident of a report upon request, although we are not required to do that,” Lawson said. “I am comfortable with that. It is important to be consistent with the policies of municipal police departments.”
In the Elon case, Nick Ochsner filed a lawsuit contending there is nearly nothing that better describes government power than the lawful authority to arrest someone.
“If an entity or a person commissioned by statute has the power of arrest, then all the records related to that would become public records,” Ann Ochsner told the supreme court.
At issue is the 2005 state law empowering campus police to enforce laws and investigate crimes. A separate law allows companies to set up police departments.
Campus and company police enforce laws just like municipal law-enforcement officers on school property, public hospitals, shopping centers and office buildings. But company and campus police are also different.
For example, they have to carry liability insurance coverage of at least $1 million an incident for personal injury or property damage.
“The issue here,” said Elon University’s attorney, Christopher Jones, “is unless you are a public law-enforcement agency, all criminal records, or records of criminal investigations, are not public.”
Amanda Martin, general counsel of the N.C. Press Association, disagreed.
“Our belief is that police departments at universities and colleges are subject to the public records law just as other public agencies exercising governmental law-enforcement functions and are not exempt because they are at private colleges,” said Martin, who filed an amicus brief last year to support the plaintiffs in the case.
Henry Gorham and Leslie Lasher, Raleigh lawyers, argued in the amicus brief for the defendants that if the supreme court rules in favor of the plaintiffs, then law-enforcement agencies’ ability to do their job will be hampered by the disclosure of investigatory techniques, witness statements and potential suspects’ identities. That could lead to “potentially erroneous reaction in the court of public opinion,” Gorham and Lasher wrote.
Gorham and Lasher couldn’t be reached Friday for comment.
The supreme court addressed private college police in 2011, ruling that Davidson College can keep its own force because the school is not so closely aligned with a religious denomination that it mixes church and state.
North Carolina has three dozen private colleges and universities educating about 87,000 students. Sixteen have campus police departments.
Other court decisions have said that a community hospital or even a private company could be considered an agency of government depending on how independent it is of government supervisory authority.
Jones argued that courts delegate to lawyers the ability to subpoena witnesses and documents, but that doesn’t make him part of state government.
Justice Paul Newby countered that lawyers don’t have the power to force someone to do something they’re unwilling to do, but must ask the courts to force the issue.
“As an attorney you have some special responsibilities. But you don’t have any power,” Newby said. “We have granted Elon University police officers the power to arrest, the power to conduct searches and seizures. These are very special and unique governmental activities. I don’t see how that is the same comparison with an attorney being able to subpoena.”
Source: Winston-Salem Journal
A reporter for a campus television news program asked Elon University’s police chief for a copy of the arrest record. What Nick Ochsner received said nothing about whether the officer had to chase down the student or how he was alleged to have resisted arrest, his mother, attorney Ann Ochsner, said.
The campus police said it didn’t have to produce anything more because, as part of a private university, a state law requiring a government agency to turn over public records on request didn’t apply.
The supreme court heard arguments Wednesday in Raleigh in a case that could define the role of officers who aren’t clearly public officials yet have arrest authority that other private employees don’t have.
Chief Regina Lawson of the Wake Forest University Police Department said Thursday that she, her agency and other police departments at the state’s private colleges are following developments in the Elon case.
“Our practice is to release the public incident of a report upon request, although we are not required to do that,” Lawson said. “I am comfortable with that. It is important to be consistent with the policies of municipal police departments.”
In the Elon case, Nick Ochsner filed a lawsuit contending there is nearly nothing that better describes government power than the lawful authority to arrest someone.
“If an entity or a person commissioned by statute has the power of arrest, then all the records related to that would become public records,” Ann Ochsner told the supreme court.
At issue is the 2005 state law empowering campus police to enforce laws and investigate crimes. A separate law allows companies to set up police departments.
Campus and company police enforce laws just like municipal law-enforcement officers on school property, public hospitals, shopping centers and office buildings. But company and campus police are also different.
For example, they have to carry liability insurance coverage of at least $1 million an incident for personal injury or property damage.
“The issue here,” said Elon University’s attorney, Christopher Jones, “is unless you are a public law-enforcement agency, all criminal records, or records of criminal investigations, are not public.”
Amanda Martin, general counsel of the N.C. Press Association, disagreed.
“Our belief is that police departments at universities and colleges are subject to the public records law just as other public agencies exercising governmental law-enforcement functions and are not exempt because they are at private colleges,” said Martin, who filed an amicus brief last year to support the plaintiffs in the case.
Henry Gorham and Leslie Lasher, Raleigh lawyers, argued in the amicus brief for the defendants that if the supreme court rules in favor of the plaintiffs, then law-enforcement agencies’ ability to do their job will be hampered by the disclosure of investigatory techniques, witness statements and potential suspects’ identities. That could lead to “potentially erroneous reaction in the court of public opinion,” Gorham and Lasher wrote.
Gorham and Lasher couldn’t be reached Friday for comment.
The supreme court addressed private college police in 2011, ruling that Davidson College can keep its own force because the school is not so closely aligned with a religious denomination that it mixes church and state.
North Carolina has three dozen private colleges and universities educating about 87,000 students. Sixteen have campus police departments.
Other court decisions have said that a community hospital or even a private company could be considered an agency of government depending on how independent it is of government supervisory authority.
Jones argued that courts delegate to lawyers the ability to subpoena witnesses and documents, but that doesn’t make him part of state government.
Justice Paul Newby countered that lawyers don’t have the power to force someone to do something they’re unwilling to do, but must ask the courts to force the issue.
“As an attorney you have some special responsibilities. But you don’t have any power,” Newby said. “We have granted Elon University police officers the power to arrest, the power to conduct searches and seizures. These are very special and unique governmental activities. I don’t see how that is the same comparison with an attorney being able to subpoena.”
Source: Winston-Salem Journal